BAKING GEAR

Best Pie Dishes for Thanksgiving Baking (2026)

Thanksgiving is the busiest pie week of the year in the United States, and the dish you bake in has a real effect on the crust. Glass lets you see the bottom browning, metal heats fastest for a crisp base, and stoneware and ceramic hold heat evenly and look lovely on the table. Each has trade-offs in weight, price and care. This guide compares four 9-inch pie dishes sold on Amazon, explains which material suits which pie and answers the questions bakers ask most often.

By · Updated October 29, 2026

How we chose: we compare maker specs, independent test data and owner feedback; we do not test products hands-on. How we research.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Our Top 3 Picks

Chooselio graphic for Emile Henry 9-Inch Pie Dish

Emile Henry 9-Inch Pie Dish

Best Overall

A 9-inch, 1.4-quart French ceramic pie dish that holds heat well, goes from freezer to oven and has a 10-year guarantee.

Pros

  • Freezer to oven
  • Oven safe to 520 F

Cons

  • Heavy
Check Price on Amazon →
Chooselio graphic for Pyrex 9-Inch Glass Pie Plate

Pyrex 9-Inch Glass Pie Plate

Best Value

The classic 9-inch Pyrex glass pie plate, made in the USA, dishwasher safe and see-through.

Pros

  • See-through glass
  • Inexpensive

Cons

  • Not deep-dish
Check Price on Amazon →
Chooselio graphic for Le Creuset Heritage Pie Dish

Le Creuset Heritage Pie Dish

Best Stoneware Dish

Le Creuset’s 9-inch Heritage stoneware pie dish with a non-porous glaze and a minus 9 to 500 F range.

Pros

  • Even baking
  • Metal-utensil safe glaze

Cons

  • Expensive for a pie dish
Check Price on Amazon →

How we chose

We did not run lab or hands-on tests for this guide. Instead we read each product’s Amazon listing and the manufacturer’s published specifications, then looked for patterns in the customer feedback summaries that Amazon shows on each listing. Where a listing gives a number, we repeat it as the listing’s claim. Where we could not find reliable details, we say so rather than guess.

We checked every Amazon listing below on October 29, 2026. We chose one strong option in each main material, glass, stoneware, ceramic and metal, so you can pick the one that suits how you bake. Several pie plates we considered, including an OXO glass dish, were showing as unavailable and were dropped.

Quick comparison

Pie dishMaterialOven limit (per listing)DishwasherNotable
Pyrex Basics 9-inchGlassPreheated oven use; see listingYesSee-through; made in USA
Le Creuset Heritage 9-inchStonewareMinus 9 to 500 FYesMetal-utensil safe; many colors
Emile Henry 9-inchBurgundy clay ceramicUp to 520 FYesFreezer to oven; 10-year guarantee
USA Pan 9-inchAluminized steel, nonstickSee manufacturerHand wash recommendedFast heating; fluted base

Glass, ceramic or metal: which pie dish is best?

Glass. Glass heats more slowly than metal but holds heat well, and you can check whether the bottom crust is golden. It is the classic choice for custard pies like pumpkin and for anyone who worries about soggy bottoms. Glass can break with sudden temperature changes, so do not put a cold glass dish into a very hot oven or set a hot one on a wet counter.

Stoneware and ceramic. These heat gently and evenly and keep pies warm on the table. They are heavy and look attractive enough to serve from, which makes them popular gifts. Brands like Emile Henry say their ceramic can go straight from the freezer to a hot oven, which is useful for make-ahead pies.

Metal. Metal pans heat quickly, which gives the crispest bottom crust, and they are light and inexpensive. They are good for blind-baking shells and for fruit pies. The downside is less heat retention once out of the oven and, for nonstick, the need to avoid sharp utensils.

Size. Most recipes are written for a 9-inch standard pie dish. Deep-dish recipes need a deeper dish; check the depth and volume before using a recipe written for a different dish, and leave room for juices to bubble.

Baking for the holidays? Our holiday cookie baking checklist helps you plan, our stand mixer guide covers the big helper, and our gifts for home bakers guide has more ideas for bakers.

Tips for a crisp bottom crust

Bake on the lowest oven rack, preheat a baking sheet and set the pie on it, and blind-bake the shell for custard pies. A sheet underneath also catches fruit juices. If the edges brown too fast, cover them with foil strips or a pie shield halfway through.

The complete reviews

Emile Henry 9-Inch Ceramic Pie Dish, 1.4 qt

Best Overall

The Emile Henry pie dish is made in France from high-fired Burgundy clay using Emile Henry’s HR ceramic, according to the listing. It is oven safe up to 520 F and broiler and microwave safe, can go directly from freezer or fridge to a hot oven, has a hard glaze that the brand says resists scratches and crazing, and is dishwasher safe. It carries a 10-year guarantee against manufacturing defects in household use.

The freezer-to-oven tolerance is ideal for Thanksgiving: assemble and freeze a pie the weekend before and bake it on the day. The ceramic keeps the pie warm on the table, and the dish looks good enough for serving.

Amazon’s customer summary is very positive: owners say it bakes evenly, feels heavy-duty, is a good depth and is easy to clean. The main drawbacks are weight and price compared with glass.

Who it’s for: Serious pie bakers who want French ceramic that holds heat, goes freezer to oven and carries a 10-year guarantee.

Who it’s not for: Skip it if these trade-offs are dealbreakers for you: heavy; costs more than glass or metal.

Chooselio graphic for Emile Henry 9-Inch Pie Dish

Pros

  • Freezer to oven
  • Oven safe to 520 F
  • 10-year guarantee

Cons

  • Heavy
  • Costs more than glass or metal
Check Price on Amazon →

Pyrex Basics 9-Inch Glass Pie Plate

Best Value

The Pyrex Basics 9-inch pie plate is non-porous glass that does not absorb odors, flavors or stains, and the listing says it is safe for preheated ovens, microwaves, fridges, freezers and dishwashers. It measures 9 x 1.2 inches, weighs about 1.5 pounds and is made in the USA.

Being able to see the bottom crust is the main reason bakers still reach for glass. It is also inexpensive enough to buy two for the holidays, and it doubles for quiche, cobblers and small casseroles.

Amazon’s customer summary says it meets expectations and is good value, with good results for pies and crustless quiches. Opinions on durability and depth are mixed; some find it shallower than they expected for deep-dish recipes.

Who it’s for: Bakers who want to see the bottom crust brown and need an affordable, made-in-USA dish that also handles casseroles.

Who it’s not for: Skip it if these trade-offs are dealbreakers for you: not deep-dish; glass can break with sudden temperature changes.

Chooselio graphic for Pyrex 9-Inch Glass Pie Plate

Pros

  • See-through glass
  • Inexpensive
  • Made in the USA

Cons

  • Not deep-dish
  • Glass can break with sudden temperature changes
Check Price on Amazon →

Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Pie Dish, 9 in

Best Stoneware Dish

The Le Creuset Heritage pie dish is stoneware with a colorful non-porous glaze that resists stains, scratches and flavor absorption, according to the listing. It has a virtually nonstick interior that resists cracking and crazing, handles temperatures from minus 9 to 500 F, and is safe in the freezer, oven, microwave, broiler and dishwasher, and with metal utensils.

It bakes evenly and makes a very attractive gift or serving dish. Being able to cut slices with a metal server without worrying about the glaze is a practical plus.

Amazon’s customer summary praises its looks, even baking and crusts, and some owners say the weight helps it hold temperature. Value opinions are mixed, and durability feedback is mixed too.

Who it’s for: Bakers who want an even-baking stoneware dish that looks good enough to serve from and tolerates metal utensils.

Who it’s not for: Skip it if these trade-offs are dealbreakers for you: expensive for a pie dish; mixed durability feedback.

Chooselio graphic for Le Creuset Heritage Pie Dish

Pros

  • Even baking
  • Metal-utensil safe glaze
  • Freezer to 500 F

Cons

  • Expensive for a pie dish
  • Mixed durability feedback
Check Price on Amazon →

USA Pan Aluminized Steel Pie Pan, 9 in

Best Metal Pan

The USA Pan 9-inch pie pan is heavy-gauge aluminized steel with a fluted surface and Americoat, a silicone-based nonstick coating that USA Pan describes as free of PTFE, PFOA and BPA. It is made in the USA.

Metal heats fastest, which helps bottom crusts set and crisp, especially for fruit pies and blind-baked shells. It is light, stacks easily and is affordable.

Amazon did not show a customer feedback summary on this listing when we checked, so we relied on USA Pan’s published details. Use non-metal tools to protect the coating, and follow USA Pan’s care guidance, which generally recommends hand washing.

Who it’s for: Bakers who want a light, fast-heating metal pan for crisp crusts at a low cost.

Chooselio graphic for USA Pan 9-Inch Pie Pan

Pros

  • Fast heating for crisp crusts
  • Light and stackable
  • Made in the USA

Cons

  • Not for serving at the table
  • Hand washing recommended
Check Price on Amazon →

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a glass or metal pie dish better?

Metal heats faster and gives the crispest bottom crust; glass heats more slowly but lets you see when the crust is browned and holds heat well. Many bakers use glass for custard pies and metal for fruit pies and blind-baked shells.

Can a glass pie dish go in the oven?

Yes. Pyrex says its glass is safe in a preheated oven. Avoid sudden temperature changes, such as moving a dish straight from the freezer to a hot oven or putting a hot dish on a cold, wet surface.

Does a pie pan need to be greased?

Usually not. Pie crust contains plenty of fat and releases from most dishes on its own. A light grease can help with crumb crusts or older, scratched pans.

Can you freeze a pie in a ceramic pie dish?

Some ceramic dishes are designed for it. Emile Henry says its dish can go straight from the freezer to a hot oven, and Le Creuset lists its stoneware as freezer safe. Check the maker’s guidance for any other dish.

Related guides

If you like Le Creuset stoneware for pies, you may also want our Le Creuset vs Staub Dutch oven comparison for braising pots.

Conclusion

The Emile Henry pie dish is our top pick for even baking, freezer-to-oven convenience and a 10-year guarantee. The Pyrex glass plate is the best value and lets you watch the crust brown, Le Creuset’s Heritage dish is the stoneware choice for serving, and the USA Pan metal pan gives the crispest crust. Check the current price on Amazon before Thanksgiving baking starts.

Back to Our Top 3 Picks ↑

Leave a Comment